Finding Affordable Car Insurance Quotes Chicago: Your Ultimate Guide

car insurance quotes chicago


When it comes to car insurance in Chicago, the costs can vary significantly based on your specific circumstances and the insurance companies you're considering. Our extensive data analysis reveals that the minimum coverage rates in Chicago are approximately 10 percent higher than the national average. It's crucial to periodically explore your options to secure the most competitive rates available.

In this comprehensive guide, we'll delve into the world of affordable car insurance in Chicago, regardless of your driving history. Whether you've had accidents in the past or a spotless record, we've got you covered.

Key Insights:

  • Our data indicates that the lowest-priced minimum coverage policies start at just $42 per month for Chicago's safe drivers.
  • For those seeking comprehensive coverage, Chicago's most budget-friendly option kicks off at a reasonable $136 per month for responsible motorists.
  • Among the standout providers, GEICO and Travelers shine as the leaders, offering the most economical minimum and full coverage, respectively.

The Best Affordable Car Insurance in Chicago


Chicago, Illinois boasts an array of top-tier car insurance providers that deliver competitive rates for both minimum and full coverage options. Additionally, these companies offer a wide range of coverage choices and exceptional customer service. Let's take a closer look at them:

1. GEICO

Our Score: 4.6
Minimum Coverage Monthly Average: $42
Full Coverage Monthly Average: $157

2. Country Financial

Our Score: 4.3
Minimum Coverage Monthly Average: $45
Full Coverage Monthly Average: $162

3. Travelers

Our Score: 4.5
Minimum Coverage Monthly Average: $47
Full Coverage Monthly Average: $136

4. Auto-Owners

Our Score: 4.4
Minimum Coverage Monthly Average: $52
Full Coverage Monthly Average: $193

Chicago Car Insurance Companies at a Glance


Here's a quick overview of the key car insurance providers in Chicago, along with their scores and average monthly rates for both minimum and full coverage:

Car Insurance Company 

Our Score 

Minimum Coverage Monthly Average 

Full Coverage Monthly Average 

State Farm 

4.7 

$53 

$184 

GEICO 

4.6 

$42 

$157 

Erie 

4.5 

$56 

$201 

Travelers 

4.5 

$47 

$136 

Auto-Owners 

4.4 

$52 

$193 

Country Financial 

4.3 

$45 

$162 

Progressive 

4.3 

$67 

$230 

Allstate 

4.1 

$101 

$339 

AAA 

4.0 

$70 

$211 

 

*Please note that all cost tables in this article represent average car insurance rates for a single, male driver aged 25 to 35, with good credit and a clean driving history. Rate data was sourced from Quadrant Information Services.

Unveiling Chicago's Car Insurance Quotes

Car insurance requirements in Chicago mandate a minimum level of coverage to provide compensation in case you're involved in an accident. Our data underscores that minimum coverage costs approximately $61 per month or $738 per year in Chicago, which is about 10 percent higher than the national average. For those seeking comprehensive coverage, which includes damage to your own vehicle, the data suggests an average cost of about $200 per month or $2,399 annually in Chicago, marking an 8 percent increase over the national average.

Discovering Affordable Liability Insurance in Chicago

Minimum coverage insurance stands out as the most economical choice in Chicago. We highly recommend considering GEICO and Country Financial, as our data reveals they offer the most affordable rates for minimum auto insurance. Responsible drivers can secure monthly rates as low as $42 with GEICO and $45 with Country Financial.


Car Insurance Company 

Monthly Minimum Coverage Average 

Annual Minimum Coverage Average 

GEICO 

$42 

$508 

Country Financial 

$45 

$546 

Travelers 

$47 

$565 

Auto-Owners 

$52 

$620 

State Farm 

$53 

$638 

Erie 

$56 

$670 

Progressive 

$67 

$808 

AAA 

$70 

$836 

Pekin 

$81 

$969 

Allstate 

$101 

$1,217 

 

Securing Affordable Full-Coverage Car Insurance in Chicago

Our data confirms that Travelers offers the most budget-friendly full-coverage insurance in Chicago, with monthly rates as low as $136. GEICO and Country Financial also provide competitive options, with monthly averages of $157 and $162, respectively. Full coverage encompasses liability, comprehensive, and collision insurance. If you have an auto loan, your lender typically requires comprehensive insurance coverage to protect your vehicle in various situations.


Car Insurance Company 

Monthly Full Coverage Average 

Annual Full Coverage Average 

Travelers 

$136 

$1,631 

GEICO 

$157 

$1,886 

Country Financial 

$162 

$1,946 

State Farm 

$184 

$2,213 

Pekin 

$185 

$2,219 

Auto-Owners 

$193 

$2,320 

Erie 

$201 

$2,417 

AAA 

$211 

$2,530 

Progressive 

$230 

$2,763 

Allstate 

$339 

$4,063 

 

How Driver Profiles Impact Car Insurance Quotes in Chicago

The cost of your car insurance in Chicago is heavily influenced by various personal factors, such as your driving history, age, vehicle, credit score, and even your Chicago ZIP code. Insurance companies assess these factors differently when determining your rates. Consequently, the insurance provider offering the lowest prices for you might not be the most cost-effective option for your neighbor. Let's explore some examples to illustrate this further.

Chicago Car Insurance Rates by ZIP Code

ZIP codes in Chicago exhibit slight variations in accident rates, vandalism incidents, and theft occurrences. These disparities can directly affect your car insurance premiums. The table below highlights how average rates can fluctuate by up to 20.8 percent, depending on your Chicago ZIP code.


Chicago ZIP Code 

Full Coverage Monthly Average 

Full Coverage Annual Average 

60657 

$164 

$1,966 

60614 

$164 

$1,972 

60618 

$181 

$2,168 

60640 

$183 

$2,197 

60634 

$188 

$2,250 

60647 

$190 

$2,274 

60625 

$190 

$2,279 

60641 

$192 

$2,306 

60632 

$206 

$2,467 

60608 

$207 

$2,480 

60629 

$208 

$2,501 

60617 

$216 

$2,587 

60639 

$218 

$2,616 

60628 

$225 

$2,698 

60620 

$227 

$2,720 

60623 

$242 

$2,898 

 

Does Your Credit Score Affect Car Insurance in Chicago?

In many states, including Illinois, insurance companies are permitted to factor in your credit score when determining your insurance rates. This is due to the observed correlation between lower credit scores and an increased likelihood of filing insurance claims. If your credit score in Chicago is less than stellar, you may find yourself facing higher insurance premiums. However, having an above-average credit score can lead to lower insurance rates.

Affordable Car Insurance in Chicago for Drivers with Poor Credit

If your credit score isn't in the best shape, we recommend exploring insurance rates from various providers. Country Financial stands out as an affordable option for drivers with poor credit, offering rates as low as $72 per month for minimum coverage and $240 per month for full coverage.


Car Insurance Company 

Monthly Minimum Coverage Average 

Monthly Full Coverage Average 

Country Financial 

$72 

$240 

Travelers 

$74 

$207 

GEICO 

$80 

$335 

Progressive 

$110 

$403 

State Farm 

$115 

$401 

Erie 

$121 

$468 

AAA 

$129 

$359 

Auto-Owners 

$147 

$585 

Pekin 

$149 

$351 

Allstate 

$167 

$512 

 

Car Insurance Costs in Chicago by Age

Car insurance rates in Chicago can vary significantly based on your age. Teenagers often face higher premiums because they are more likely to engage in risky driving behaviors, leading to a higher frequency of accidents and traffic violations. In Chicago, 16-year-olds insuring their own vehicles can expect to pay approximately $241 per month for minimum coverage or a hefty $728 per month for full coverage. As drivers progress into their 20s and beyond, insurance rates tend to decrease. Typically, car insurance is most affordable for drivers between the ages of 35 and 55. Seniors may see slightly higher rates due to an increased risk of accidents. Here's a breakdown of average rates for minimum and full coverage car insurance in Chicago, categorized by age:

Driver Age 

Monthly Minimum Coverage Average 

Monthly Full Coverage Average 

16 

$241 

$728 

25 

$66 

$218 

30 

$61 

$200 

35 

$57 

$182 

45 

$54 

$169 

55 

$52 

$159 

 

Affordable Car Insurance in Chicago for Teen Drivers

While auto insurance rates for teenagers tend to be higher, some insurance companies offer more budget-friendly options than others. For instance, Country Financial stands out as one of the most cost-effective choices for teen drivers, offering minimum coverage rates as low as $116 per month and full-coverage rates of $381 per month. Erie and GEICO also provide affordable options for 16-year-olds.


Car Insurance Company 

Monthly Minimum Coverage Average 

Monthly Full Coverage Average 

Country Financial 

$116 

$381 

Erie 

$128 

$480 

GEICO 

$158 

$620 

Auto-Owners 

$198 

$580 

State Farm 

$206 

$640 

AAA 

$273 

$820 

Pekin 

$307 

$519 

Travelers 

$313 

$981 

Progressive 

$319 

$1,181 

Allstate 

$392 

$1,075 

 

The Impact of Driving Records on Car Insurance Costs in Chicago

If you have a history of causing accidents or receiving speeding tickets, you can expect your car insurance rates to increase. Typically, accidents and tickets affect your rates for a duration of three years. Our data highlights that drivers with a speeding ticket can face a 26 percent increase in insurance costs, while at-fault accidents can lead to a 51 percent increase, and a DUI or DWI can result in an astounding 83 percent rate hike. Several insurance companies are known for offering competitive rates to drivers with different types of violations. Below are average rates for drivers with speeding tickets, at-fault accidents, or DUIs:


Car Insurance Company 

Monthly Minimum Coverage Average 

Monthly Full Coverage Average 

State Farm 

$60 

$205 

Travelers 

$63 

$185 

Country Financial 

$69 

$232 

Erie 

$79 

$276 

GEICO 

$80 

$292 

Progressive 

$80 

$291 

Auto-Owners 

$83 

$287 

AAA 

$130 

$325 

Pekin 

$131 

$285 

Allstate 

$170 

$533 

 

Affordable Car Insurance in Chicago After a Speeding Ticket

Wondering which insurance company offers the most affordable rates following a speeding ticket? Our rate data suggests that drivers can secure low minimum coverage rates with GEICO at just $53 per month, on average.

  • Affordable Car Insurance in Chicago After an At-Fault Accident

At-fault accidents can have a substantial impact on your insurance rates, often leading to higher premiums compared to speeding tickets. Among the options for minimum coverage, Travelers stands out as the most affordable, with an average monthly rate of $61. For full-coverage insurance, Travelers offers competitive rates at $181 per month. It's evident that there can be a significant difference in rates between insurance providers for drivers with at-fault accidents


Car Insurance Company 

Monthly Minimum Coverage Average 

Monthly Full Coverage Average 

Travelers 

$61 

$181 

State Farm 

$63 

$216 

Auto-Owners 

$69 

$246 

Country Financial 

$72 

$236 

Erie 

$79 

$276 

GEICO 

$85 

$310 

Progressive 

$88 

$329 

AAA 

$106 

$266 

Pekin 

$110 

$243 

Allstate 

$198 

$622 

 

  • Affordable Car Insurance in Chicago After a DUI

Getting convicted of driving under the influence (DUI) can significantly impact your driving record and result in substantially higher insurance rates. In some cases, traditional insurance companies may even refuse to provide coverage if you have multiple DUIs and other violations on your record. For Chicago drivers with a DUI, State Farm emerges as the most budget-friendly option for minimum coverage, offering rates as low as $58 per month. When it comes to full-coverage insurance, Travelers offers attractive monthly rates averaging $198.


Car Insurance Company 

Monthly Minimum Coverage Average 

Monthly Full Coverage Average 

State Farm 

$58 

$199 

Travelers 

$69 

$198 

Progressive 

$73 

$257 

Country Financial 

$75 

$248 

Erie 

$97 

$329 

GEICO 

$101 

$363 

Auto-Owners 

$109 

$366 

Allstate 

$172 

$532 

Pekin 

$178 

$380 

AAA 

$197 

$449 

 

Car Insurance Requirements in Chicago

Chicago drivers are obligated to maintain a minimum-coverage policy, which includes bodily injury liability coverage and property damage liability coverage. These requirements aim to ensure that individuals can provide compensation to others in the event they are responsible for causing an accident. The specific requirements mandated by the state of Illinois are as follows:


  • $50,000 bodily injury liability coverage per accident
  • $25,000 bodily injury liability coverage per person
  • $20,000 property damage liability coverage per accident
  • $50,000 underinsured/uninsured motorist bodily injury coverage per accident
  • $25,000 underinsured/uninsured motorist bodily injury coverage per person


Types of Car Insurance Coverage

Car insurance coverage comes in various forms, each designed to protect against different types of risks. Here's a breakdown of the common types of car insurance coverage:


  • Liability: This coverage includes bodily injury (BI) liability insurance, which pays for the medical expenses of other drivers and their passengers if you're at fault in an accident. It also includes property damage (PD) liability insurance, which covers the damages to other drivers' vehicles after an accident for which you're at fault.
  • Collision: Collision insurance pays for damages to your vehicle resulting from a collision with another vehicle or a road hazard.
  • Comprehensive: Comprehensive insurance covers damages to your vehicle caused by events such as accidents involving animals, natural disasters, theft, and vandalism.
  • Medical Payments Coverage (MedPay): MedPay covers medical bills for you and your passengers after an accident.
  • Personal Injury Protection (PIP): PIP also covers medical bills for you and your passengers after an accident, and it can also cover lost wages.
  • Underinsured/Uninsured Motorist Coverage (UM/UIM): UM/UIM coverage protects you and your passengers in the event of an accident with a driver who is underinsured or has no insurance. It includes property damages (UMPD/UIMPD) and bodily injuries (UMBI/UIMBI).


Affordable Car Insurance in Chicago: Our Recommendations

On average, Chicago drivers face insurance rates that are about 10 percent higher than the national average. However, by exploring your options and shopping wisely, you can find more competitive prices. After examining full- and minimum-coverage rates for various scenarios, we recommend considering GEICO, Travelers, Auto-Owners, and Country Financial as some of the most affordable choices for auto insurance in Chicago.


To find the best rates in Illinois, it's essential to compare free quotes from different insurance companies. We advise obtaining at least three quotes each time you shop for insurance.


Cheapest Auto Insurance in Chicago: Frequently Asked Questions

Here are some commonly asked questions regarding the cheapest auto insurance in Chicago:


How much is car insurance in Chicago?

Based on our rate data, good drivers in Chicago can expect to pay around $61 per month or $738 per year for minimum-coverage insurance on average. For full-coverage insurance, rates are approximately $200 per month or $2,399 per year.


Is car insurance higher in Chicago?

The average cost of full-coverage insurance in Chicago is roughly $2,399 per year. This is approximately 56 percent higher than the Illinois average of $1,677 and 8 percent higher than the national average of $2,216.


How much is car insurance in Illinois per month?

Minimum-coverage car insurance in Illinois costs an average of $39 per month or $472 per year. Full-coverage auto insurance averages $140 per month or $1,677 per year.


What is the best car insurance company in Illinois?

The best car insurance company in Illinois, according to our ratings, is GEICO, which receives a score of 4.6 out of 5. Our scoring takes into account factors such as cost, coverage, reliability, and service.


Our Review Process

Our review process aims to provide consistent and unbiased evaluations of car insurance providers. While there are several qualities that make an auto insurance company successful, our review team focuses on those that we believe are most significant for consumers:


Cost: Comparing costs between insurers can be challenging due to the many factors influencing annual premiums. What's most affordable for one driver may not be the same for another. To determine our cost score, we consider insurance rate estimates from Quadrant Information Services, available discounts, and consumer reports.


Coverage: Our coverage score assesses the number of coverage options available, as well as coverage limits and deductible options. We also take into account additional services and benefits, such as roadside assistance.


Reliability: We prioritize companies with a strong financial strength rating from AM Best, indicating their ability to meet claims obligations. Established insurers with a history of reliable service also receive higher ratings.


Service: To gauge customer experiences, we review  customer reviews on platforms like the Better Business Bureau (BBB). Insurers with a low volume of complaints receive favorable scores in this area. We also assess the claims process, giving higher ratings to car insurance providers that offer user-friendly claims apps.


Insurance rate data has been sourced from Quadrant Information Services and is accurate at the time of publication.


Comments